Featured Post

Ice Cream Chronicles - New Interactive Map

As you may have noticed, a new interactive Google Map containing all the location and links to all my Ice Cream Chronicles posts is now acce...

The Greater Columbus Pizza-politan Area

The Ohio State University Campus: a heavy (unsurprisingly) pizza area
As covered in my last blog post, a simple question about Worthington being the pizza capital in terms of ratio of pizza to people proved to be a lot more complicated than I would have thought at first glance. A lot of it has to do with geography - ragged city borders from years of annexation and the normal flow of business means some popular destinations for the city's residents are actually not in Worthington proper.  But as a countering force, there is a hometown pizza aspect that does drive diners to prefer one pizza place over another.

With obviously other factors at play like price and convenience, I figured that a bigger picture was needed and that all pizza places in the area needed to be mapped. Who knows, similarly sized suburbs like Bexley or Grandview Heights might be more pizza-rich than Worthington, or maybe I could pinpoint some relative pizza hot spots. So a couple weeks after I started looking into the topic, I broke out my Google Maps and centered it on the Columbus area and punched in the word "pizza".

A screen grab of what happens when you're doggedly determined
to finish what you started
The process seemed simple at first - click, add, repeat...click, add, repeat - until I realized that the map I was creating was turning into a cluster to navigate. A truckload of seemingly random blue markers does not a good reference map make, with nothing to distinguish a standard chain (Domino's) from one of note (the Short North's Paulie Gee's) from a local favorite (the campus area's Adriatico's). In addition, the increasingly lengthening list of places on the map index had no real organization to it - alphabetical order may be boring but it in this case was badly needed.

I didn't write this blog post to be an elongated primer on how to create a Google map, but suffice it to say, a new strategy was needed to make this a reality. Over the next several weeks, I subdivided the places into logical group layers (National Top 100 Chains, for example), diversified the icon colors and icons themselves, and painstakingly alphabetized each list (a tedious drag and drop affair.) 

So, without further adieu, this is what resulted: the big map of the Greater Columbus Pizza-politan Area:

A few notes: this is intended to be a map that is continuously edited until, well, I don't feel like editing it anymore.  As you may see in scrolling through the layers, there are already some changes, with various closures that have been logoed with the dreaded "X" (such as PizzaRev).  I figured for historical purposes I'd keep the closures around until a new pizza place took over the address. I probably also missed a few places - any additions that you the reader might want to put in will definitely go under consideration.

You'll also notice some places that are undergoing transition with a violet color - these places include Bono Pizza (adapting to the food truck model with the closure of their brick and mortar), Adriatico's (set to be relocated once the planned demolition of their current location takes place) and Plank's Bier Garten (still awaiting reopening after their December 2016 fire).

One of the fun things was doing some research on some of the places mapped and digging up various media and blog sources both old and new.  Links to posts from numerous local bloggers (especially the local guru of pizza in the venerable CMH Gourmand) are added to various locations to add variety; at the minimum, I hope to include add at least one relevant link to each place mapped over time (this is still an ongoing process.)

Finally, I want to state that my map is imperfect, and its imperfection is an issue that may never be fully resolved. My main goal was to include places that were takeout pizza places, or whose menu was really centered on pizza (Pizza House and Natalie's Coal Fired come to mind.) When it came to Full-Service Restaurants, I reached a bit of a conundrum. I had intended to only include traditional Italian joints like Villa Nova and TAT Ristorante di Famiglia.

TAT Ristorante di Famiglia, the Eastmoor institution that has been serving
up pizzas and other Italian standards for over 80 years
But then I thought about the great pizza that the Short North's Forno has while also realizing that their menu that goes well beyond pizza. It seemed ridiculous to leave them off the list (I did leave them on), but then soon realized shortly after that a truly time-consuming effort awaits me if I wish to complete this particular level. I mean, how can you really include every such restaurant which happens to have pizza, from the fancy (Marcella's), to the fast food realm (Fazoli's), to the "who woulda' thunk" field (Yogi's Hoagies and Be Fit Cafe.) This layer I will add to over time, but I'd like to hear your best pizza from these types of eateries.

And then something more philosophical crossed my mind - many restaurants tout flatbread as an item: should that count the same as pizza? How about the unique hybrid that Viiza, which is slated to arrive downtown this year; should that qualify?  And what about grocery/specialty retailers like Costco, Sam's Club and Giant Eagle, who do tons of business in both fresh-baked and take-and-bake pies?

So I guess in the end, the original question of whether Worthington is the pizza capital of Central Ohio will remain unanswered. However, I think what resulted from that quest should prove useful in searching out your own personal hot spots (a couple that come to mind for me reside in the Pizza House/Leone's pairing in Salem Village and Rubino's and Bexley Pizza Plus in Bexley).

Also, I hope it will encourage your own sense of exploration to seek out a previously unknown pie spot for you.  Will Brice's Little Sicily's creations strike new chords of red sauce love in your heart?  Perhaps Franklinton's Josie's has a everybody-should-get-this-pie that few outside the area know about?

To paraphrase a travel blessing I've heard often, may the dough rise up to meet you, may the spice be always in your sauce, and may the cheese melt upon your face.


  1. Speaking as CMH Gourmand, the student has become the master. Even I would not take on this Herculean task of the map. Merely tracking and updating Taco Trucks soon turned out to be Sisyphean.

    Pizza and Columbus go hand in hand. At one point in the 1990's. it was determined that Columbus has more pizza places per capita than ANY city in the country. I attribute this in part to our proximity to West Virginia which as as state has the largest percentage of pizza places.

    My series years ago took a loosely defined interpretation of pizza places in Clintonville in an effort to determine the best. This is how the series summed up -> https://cmhgourmand.com/2012/04/19/clintonville-pizza-challenge-the-verdict-with-a-serving-of-unsolicited-pizza-philosophy/

    Also interesting, six years later, many of the places from the series are gone: Romeos (replaced by Sbarro - I predict it will be gone by 2019), Belleria Pizza - Gone, replaced by new owners, Pizza Mart - gone, replaced by Pizza Mart, Z Pizza = gone replaced by East Coast. Whole World - although not sampled has closed. An interesting trend there - a pizza place, tends to be replaced by a pizza place.

    Although the Clintonville Pizz challenge has not be recreated I can say of the available choices Hounddogs and Pizza House are the two we consume in our home. We are at the fringe of Hounddogs delivery zone and my wife loves Pizza House's meatball subs. While we appreciate the technical goodness of Harvest Pizza the price and not being kid friendly keep that out of meaningful rotation. About once per year I get a Dante's (the first pizza I ever consumed....ever) or Gato's just to recalibrate my Clintonville Pizza Palate and then we go back our standards. I am happy to have Leone's in the borderlands but have found them to inconsistent and when we order pizza on our house, it has to be a win every time. I will also admit that Jet's is delivered to our house with great frequency when I am good all weekend. And a final note reviewing the old series, I did not indicate that Clintonville based chains - Dominos, Donatos and Pizza Hut were excluded.

    Continue with your good work and perhaps we will unite to do a Worthington/Clintonville Pizza Grand Prix house party this year where we get one pizza from each place in the geo-zone and have them all go head to head.

    1. Thanks! I'm still far from being a master at pizza, but I think what came of this will definitely help me out in figuring out what's out there in pizza land. And it would be fun to try to get going another area pizza grand prix - there are a few places out there that might that are out there relatively nearby but haven't gotten to such as East Coast and Big Tony's.